Parenthoodroutine.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
Best Baby Pacifiers of 2023: Complete Reviews & Comparison
There’s no better method to calming your little one for the day with the best baby pacifier. Not every infant is the same, but some of them do require a bit of extra attention. If your child is crying or still learning how to suckle, then a baby pacifier can be helpful. Whether it’s during the day, at night, or for playtime, the best baby pacifiers can help keep your child relaxed and focused.
Such a product can help with promoting good mouth health, help keep your child occupied, and prevent them from stressing out. Besides that, these items can help lull your child to sleep and make them feel more relaxed during nap or bedtime. Either way, they are beneficial and have been a known tradition for years.
Now, there are many different types of baby suckers available on the market. As a mom, you want the best for your little one. With so many options, it can be challenging to know that the purchase you’re about to make it worth the investment. We know how frustrating it is to spend the hard-earned money on bad products that need to be replaced. Hence, we put together a comprehensive guide to help you choose the best products for your needs.
In this article, we will be introducing you to the top best baby pacifiers 2023 has to offer.
The 10 Best Baby Pacifiers
The Philips Avent Pacifier helps promote healthy oral development for your child. This item is designed to help relax and is a baby soother for your infants with a queue rounded shape. It’s built with durable hospital-grade silicone and is made to be long-lasting. There’s no detectable taste, ensuring that your baby will be relaxed while using it.
Besides this, the item is designed to be easy to sterilize and clean. All you will need to do is put it in a pot of hot water and boil for five minutes at a time.
However, if you’re a busy mom, it’s good to know that Philips is also dishwasher safe. Plus, one of the cutest pink pacifiers you’ll find.
Why We Like It
- Comfortable
- Durable
- Supports oral development
- Easy to clean
- BPA free
The next on our best pacifier for a newborn list is the MAM Pacifiers. These are designed to keep your newborn calm as a newborn soother during the night while also helping promote healthy oral development. The item features a skin-soft nipple that’s box breathable and comfortable. On top of that, the material is made from silicone and features a glow in the dark mouthpiece.
There's an anti-slip textured material on the nipple to help prevent the item from slipping out. Plus, the nipple is symmetrical and helps promote your baby’s developing mouth. Other than that, it features a curved shelf which makes it more comfortable when your baby’s using it.
Lastly, the item includes small openings on the surface to help allow air to circulate. This helps prevent your child from choking. The cause is also reusable, and sterilization can be done in the microwave.
Why We Like It
- Promotes dental health
- Breathable
- Soft
- Glows in the dark
- Easy to clean
The next item on our list is the NUK Pacifier. This item features a silicone design with a slight contour to help prevent marking your baby’s skin. The orthodontic nipple shape helps promote healthy dental health. Plus, the heart-shaped shields contours your baby’s face and prevents them from choking.
Each item is BPA-free, is made from silicone, and ideal for those 0-6 months old.
If you’re a busy mom, being able to sanitize a pacifier comes in handy quickly. The NUK can either be placed into the dishwasher or put into the microwave to be cleaned.
Why We Like It
- Silicone material
- Orthodontic shape
- Bpa free
- Easy to breathe
- Easy to sanitize
The Tommee Tippee item is the next on our list. It features a baby approved nipple shape, which is proven to have at least 78% acceptance from newborns. The product includes natural oral development support, which can help promote healthy teeth. Plus, it consists of a bottle nipple shape, which is more comfortable for a baby to suck on.
The item doesn’t include any BPA’s, ensuring that it’s safe to use. However, the material also glows in the dark, which can keep your baby calm at night.
It’s ideal for young infants to toddlers and includes a symmetrical orthodontic shape. The only downside we’ve found was that glow in the dark isn’t that bright.
Pros
- Promotes oral health
- Nipple shape
- BPA free
- Glow in the dark
Cons
- Glow isn’t that strong
The next on our list is Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci item. The product includes a nipple-like shape, with one-piece construction. The device is made from high-grade silicone and is lightweight and breathable.
Besides this, the product includes a butterfly shape, which helps contour to the curves of your baby’s face. This allows them to breathe easier and prevents the product from falling out of their mouth. As for cleaning, the item can be placed into the dishwasher.
The only issue we’ve come across is that the nipple is very long, which makes it difficult for the baby to keep it in their mouths when young. We suggest getting this for a slightly older infant, as then they will be able to keep it in their mouth.
Pros
- Nipple like shape
- Lightweight
- Easy to breathe
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Long nipple, may be hard to keep in mouth
The next on our best pacifier for a newborn list is the Itzy Ritzy Pacifier Set. This product is constructed with durable, latex-free silicone and has a collapsible handle for better safety.
It contains no BPA contaminants or PVC, making it completely safe to use. The only materials used are food-grade silicone. Plus, the product meets ASTM safety standards and has two large vent holes for improved breathability.
The only downside is that it can be too heavy for some infants below 5 months.
Pros
- High quality
- BPA and PVC-free
- 100% food-grade silicone
- Collapsible handle
Cons
- Can be too heavy for some infants
The next on our list is the Chicco PhysioForma item. It features a unique design that’s promised to help with your baby’s breathing. It’s clinically developed and has already been tested and approved by leading professionals. This includes neonatologists, pediatricians, and orthodontists.
Other than that, it features a lateral curve on the nipple, which helps evenly distribute weight. The tiny ridges can help prevent the item from slipping out. Plus, the item is made from 100% silicone, which is both BPA and latex-free. Each item also contains ventilation holes, making it easier for your child to breathe.
The only downside we’ve found with this is that a lot of lint, fuzz, etc. will get stuck on them.
textPros
- Promotes healthy breathing
- Clinically developed
- Stays in the infant's mouth
- BPA-free
Cons
- Attracts lint and dirt
One of the last on our list is the BIBS Baby Pacifier. It includes 100% natural rubber in multiple vintage colors. These pacifiers are designed to self-soothe your child by promoting their sucking instincts. The nipple is designed to mimic a mother's breast shape, which helps the infant feel comfortable.
Each package includes two pacifiers in size one. However, there are different sizes available for various aged toddlers and infants. Every item included in the package is BPA-free and free from PVC and phthalates.
The only downside we’ve found is that they only last two months, which means you’ll need to repurchase them.
Pros
- Natural materials
- Promote sucking
- Mimics nipple shape
- Multiple sizes available
- BPA-free
Cons
- Two-month lifespan
The WubbaNub Infant item is one of the last we have to review. It includes a cute animal plush with the purchase of an infant pacifier. This version contains a cute giraffe plush which is attached to the end of the pacifier. As for the nipple, it’s shaped to be easy to use and grasp.
Other than that, it’s crafted using medical-grade silicone, which is safe for infants and toddlers. The item is free from BPA, PVC, and phthalate materials. The company only recommends it for newborns to six months olds. Otherwise, the product is too small.
The only downside we’ve found it difficult to wash because the plush animal is in the way.
Pros
- Nipple shape
- Medical grade silicone
- BPA-free
- Only Infants
Cons
- Hard to clean
The last best newborn pacifiers on our list are the Philips Avent Soothie items. It’s perfectly sized for your baby’s mouth, and the shape is similar to a mother’s nipple. All materials used are latex and BPA-free. The material used to craft the item is hospital-grade silicone, making it safe to use. Other than that, it features a durable one-piece design.
The only downside is that the nipple end may be too big for newborn babies. However, it’s the best pacifier for newborns.
Pros
- Nipple shape
- Latex Free
- BPA-free
- Hospital-grade
Cons
- A bit big for newborns
Buyer’s Guide
Now that we’ve covered anything else, it’s time to give you a proper breakdown of what types of items are available. As always, this is a simple guide, but you can find more information online. Plus, learning how to select your pacifier can help if you haven’t found one of the ones on our best pacifier of the 2023 list. Plus, be sure to check out the best bottle for breastfed baby and also best baby bibs, our other articles.
When to Use Pacifiers
Generally, you will not want to use a pacifier with an infant under 3-4 weeks of age. This is because they are still rapidly growing, and such an item may interrupt their natural oral health. Once they’re of age, you can start to incorporate a pacifier into their routine.
We always see mothers use a pacifier as their first method to calm their child down. However, all this does is create a dependency, which you want to avoid. Instead, use such an item as a last resort or as a method to get your infant familiar when they should be sleepy or relaxing. To do so, use the item before nap time, bedtime, and even activities such as car rides. Other than that, avoid using it too much.
How to Choose the Best Baby Pacifiers
It may be challenging to choose the best newborn pacifiers because every child is different. However, learning how to identify cheap pacifiers from a good one still comes in handy. With so many options out there, we can’t stress enough when to steer clear of specific items. Here’s a quick overview of what to keep an eye out for:
- Look for BPA-free/PVC-free materials
- Find the right size! (ex: 0-6 months, 6+m, etc.)
- Regular, hospital grade, or orthodontic types
- Look for items that promote ventilation/contoured bodies
- If all else fails, try a different type.
Best Baby Pacifier Types
Here’s a quick rundown of the different types of baby pacifier types.
Orthodontic
Orthodontic products are designed to help promote healthy oral health. Each pacifier helps correct misalignment and promotes correct teeth growing. They also help your infant learn how to suckle, which comes in handy for breastfeeding. Medical centers have tested these types of items and been proven to work.
Latex
Some items will be made out of latex. While latex is a very lightweight and soft material, it does have its drawbacks. You will want to avoid these types if your child has a latex sensitivity. However, if you’re looking for a disposable latex pacifier that will last for a short amount of time, then these will work.
Rubber
The next type is a rubber one. These types are ideal for those looking for a more thick yet durable pacifier. They don’t contain any BPA, PVC, or harmful materials and often prevents debris from sticking to the baby binky.
Silicone
The last type are silicone ones. These are generally used in hospitals. If you’re looking for a semi-smooth pacifier that mimics the feeling of a real nipple, then this will work. Other than that, it’s the easiest to clean and is the most comfortable for infants.
Are Pacifiers Bad?
The truth is, items can be both good and bad for your baby. Every mom should consider the positives and negatives before choosing to use a pacifier. While some children may enjoy using such a product, others may prefer not to use one or to suckle on their fingers or thumb. So, it will be high up to you and your child.
Here’s a quick overview of the positives for using pacifiers with your children
- Helps soothe crying babies to sleep
- Distract infants after baths, checkups, etc.
- Helps lull your baby to sleep
- Ease discomfort during flights
- Reduce sudden death syndrome (SIDS)
- Helps generalize to finger or nipple sucking
- Promotes healthy sucking
- Promotes dental development
Now, here’s an overview of the negatives of using a pacifier
- On infants, the use may interfere with breastfeeding
- The baby may become dependent on the item to feel relaxed
It may increase middle ear infections
Prolonging use could lead to dental problems if not stopped when older
As you can see, there are plenty of benefits and drawbacks. However, we leave it up to the mother to decide if she wants to use a pacifier on her child. Every child is different, which means some may not like pacifiers, while others may love them. Although, we don’t see the harm in at least trying a pacifier when your infant is at least four weeks or older. If they don’t like it, you can always take it away and switch back to something else.
Our Recommendation for 2023 - Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Pink/Purple
Among the best baby pacifiers 2023 hast offer, we consider the Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Pink/Purple to be the most impressive. It checks all of our lists when it comes to material type, shape, and being lightweight. However, it’s only for infants 0-3 months old. If your child is older than that, we suggest looking at another on our list.
As we always suggest, keep an eye out for the positives and negatives of each pacifier. You need to find one that works for you and your infant. Each infant is different, so if you know they prefer rubber pacifiers, then find rubber ones. Other factors to keep an eye out for are BPA free, PVC free, and other credentials such as orthogonal/medical testing.
Pacifiers can help soothe your child and keep them calm. While they shouldn’t be used as your first line of defense, they can be used to help keep your child relaxed at specific times. Use pacifiers to help promote proper sucking, oral health, and to help keep them relaxed during daily activities.
related reviews
-
-
-
-
-
COMMENTS